| Transcript of Hearing on 11th September 2026 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00034 - University of Dundee - Email chain between John Connell (University of Dundee) and Gillian Boyd (University of Dundee) - regarding approving correspondence to Eljamel - 18/04/2014 - 19/04/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00135 - University of Dundee - Email from Gillian Stott (University of Dundee) to John Connell (University of Dundee) - regarding letter to approve for Mr Eljamel - 18/04/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00022 - University of Dundee - Letter from John Connell (University of Dundee) to Dr Andrew Russell (NHS Tayside) acknowledging outcome of Mr Eljamel's application for retirement - 25/02/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00033 - University of Dundee - Email chain between John Connell (University of Dundee) and Andrew Russell (NHS Tayside) - regarding Eljamel's suspension - 04/02/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00130- University of Dundee - Email from Gillian Stott (UOD) to John Connell (UOD) - requesting update on Eljamel - 28/01/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00042- University of Dundee - Email from John Connell (UOD) to Sam Eljamel - regarding retirement and stopping honorary contract with UOD - 21/03/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00112- University of Dundee - Minutes and Report of Senate Meeting - 25/09/2013 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00067- University of Dundee - Email chain from Jill Belch (UOD)to John Connell (UOD) - regarding review of Eljamel's research and honorary status - 04/04/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-01435- University of Dundee - Witness Statement of Professor John Connell - 07/05/2026 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00115- University of Dundee - Email chain from Gillian Stott (UOD) to John Connell (UOD), David Mowle (NHS Tayside) - regarding Eljamel suspension & research projects - 19/12/2013 - 20/12/2013 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00066- University of Dundee - Email chain from Jill Belch (UOD) to Catrina Forde (UOD) - regarding Eljamel research projects - 17/01/2014 - 27/01/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00136- University of Dundee - Letter from Gillian Boyd - Stott (UOD) to Sam Eljamel - confirming end of Honorary status - 16/04/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00027- University of Dundee - Letter from Andrew Russell (NHST) to John Connell (UOD) - concerning Eljamel's suspension from duty - 17/02/2014 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00023- University of Dundee - CV of Mr Eljamel - 30/04/2009 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00143- University of Dundee - CV of Mr Eljamel - May 2009 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00028- University of Dundee- Letter from Mr Eljamel to Brian Burchell (UOD) - regarding request for promotion - 29/10/2004 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-00149- University of Dundee - Timeline of Key Staff Members - 1990 - 2026 |
Section 1 |
| UNID-01436- University of Dundee - Witness Statement of Rory McCrimmon - 12/05/2026 |
Section 1 |
| Transcript of Section 1 Hearing on 10th September 2026 |
Section 1 |
| CHG-00286_045-048 - CHG - FH Partnership Limited Clinical Governance Report - 04/11/2014 |
Section 1 |
| CHG-00288- CHG - Email chain between BMI colleagues regarding Mr Eljamel investigation - 19/12/2013 - 13/08/2015 |
Section 1 |
| CHG-00287- CHG - Email chain from Mark Ferreira (BMI) to Louise Buchan (BMI) - 01/08/2014 |
Section 1 |
| CHG-00248 - CHG- Record of treatment codes 01/01/2005 - 01/01/2013 |
Section 1 |
| CHG-00245 - Circle Health Group - Witness Statement of Peter James, Chief Medical Officer, Circle Health Group - 13/05/2026 |
Section 1 |
| HIS-00011 Healthcare Improvement Scotland - From Readiness to Revalidation: A Report on Medical Revalidation Progress in 2012-2013 - October 2013 |
Section 1 |
| HIS-00018 Healthcare Improvement Scotland - Sharing Intelligence for Health and Care Group NHS Tayside review - 17/08/2015 |
Section 1 |
| HIS-00047 - Healthcare Improvement Scotland - Witness Statement - Robbie Pearson, Chief Executive, Healthcare Improvement Scotland - 16/03/2026 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01656 - NHS Tayside - Letter from Lee Jordan (NHS Tayside) to Annie Ingram (NHS Tayside) and Peter Stonebridge (NHS Tayside) - 16/11/2018 |
Section 1 |
| NHSL-00088 - NHSL - Witness Statement - Tracey Gillies - 25/02/2026 |
Section 1 |
| NHSL-00012 - NHSL - Review of NHS Tayside's Investigation of Professor Eljamel - 08/04/2019 |
Section 1 |
| NHSL-00006 - NHS Lothian - Email chain from Annie Ingram to Tracey Gillies, Peter Stonebridge and colleagues Discussing enquiries into Neurosurgery - 12/09/2018 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-00071 - NHS Tayside - Letter from Steven Wakeling (Royal College of Surgeons of England) to Dr Russell (NHS Tayside) - regarding review of Eljamel's clinical work - 04/10/2013 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01581 - NHS Tayside - Letter from Clare Marx (RCS) to Andrew Russell (NHS Tayside) - RCS Report into Professor Eljamel - 06/12/2013 |
Section 1 |
| RCS-00012- RCS- Professional Standards and Regulation Division - The Invited Review Mechanism Regulations for Individual Reviews - February 2013 |
Section 1 |
| RCS-00014- RCS Invited Review Mechanism: An Invited Review Report on Behalf Of: The Royal College of Surgeons of England and Society of British Neurological Surgeons Report on Professor Muftah Salem Eljamel - 17/09/2013 |
Section 1 |
| RCS-00021- RCS- Witness Statement - Frank Smith, Emeritus Professor of Vascular Surgery and Surgical Education, the University of Bristol - 26/02/2026 |
Section 1 |
| Transcript of Section 1 Hearing on 9th September 2026 |
Section 1 |
| PSC-00007 - PSC - First Do No Harm - Report of Independent Medicines and Medical Devices Safety Review - 08/07/2020 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| PSC-00006 - PSC - Patient Safety Commissioner (Scotland) - Patient Safety Charter v1 - Undated [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| PSC-00005 - PSC - Patient Safety Commissioner (Scotland) - Key Principles for the PSC Scotland Office - v1 - Undated [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| PSC-00001 - PSC - Witness Statement of Karen Titchener, Patient Safety Commissioner - 13/07/2026 |
Section 1 |
| NES-00083- NES - Witness Statement of Emma Watson - 18/03/2026 |
Section 1 |
| ELJ-00559 - Patient Safety Commissioner for Scotland Act 2023 - 07/11/2023 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| Transcript of Section 1 Hearing on 8th September 2026 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04495 - Timeline of Receipt and Steps to Implement Do Not Destroy Notice - 26/04/2023 - 18/11/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01697 - Email from NHS Tayside - communication regarding Vital Signs newsletter - 09/09/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01592 - Email from Tayside Communications to NHS Tayside - regarding Do Not Destroy Notice - 08/11/2024 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04504 - Agenda for Eljamel Oversight Board, Destruction of Theatre Logbooks - 12/09/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04506 - Email from Margaret Dunning (Ninewells Hospital and Medical School Dundee) to Colleagues - 18/10/2024 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04697 - Letter from Nicky Connor (NHS Tayside) to Lynn Smith (NHS Tayside) - discussing Operation Stringent - 18/09/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-05239 - AAB Independent Review Report: Destruction of Theatre Logbooks - NHS Tayside - August 2026 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04507 - NHS Scotland Workforce Policies Investigation Report - 30/10/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01484 - Scottish Government Records Management: Health and Social Care Code of Practice (Scotland) 2020 - 18/05/2020 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01483 - Health Records Operational Guidance and Service Operational Procedures Version 19 - April 2024 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01539 - Governance: Health Records Strategy and Management Policy - Version 9.0 - February 2025 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| NHST-04724 - NHS Tayside Chief Executive Team Update - regarding Do Not Destroy Notice timeline and follow-up actions - 15/09/2025 |
Section 1 |
| NHST-01485 - NHS Tayside - Email Chain between Pamela Johnston (NHS Tayside) and NHS Tayside Colleagues - regarding retention of records amid Do Not Destroy Order - 24/04/2023 to 26/04/2023 |
Section 1 |
| ELJ-00538 - Eljamel Inquiry - Opening statement on behalf of NHS Tayside – 19/11/2025 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| RCSE-00228 - RCSE - Witness Statement of Mark Egan, Chief Executive, RCS Edinburgh - 20/03/2026 |
Section 1 |
| RCSE-00092 - RCSE - The Herald - Surgeon suspended over claim of error in operation - 20/05/2014 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| RCSE-00091 - RCSE - Email from Aoife O'Sullivan (RCSEd) to Fiona Sinclair (RCSEd) - regarding Eljamel's suspension and fellowship information - 17/05/2014 to 27/05/2014 |
Section 1 |
| RCSE-00090 - RCSE - Email chain from Irene MacDonald (RCSEd) to Mr Eljamel - regarding concerns with RCS - 22/05/2014 to 03/04/2025 |
Section 1 |
| ELJ-00534 - Eljamel Inquiry - Letter from the Eljamel Inquiry to Nicky Connor (NHS Tayside) - regarding Do Not Destroy Notice - 11/10/2024 |
Section 1 |
| RCSE-00011 - RCSE - Email chain from Aoife O'Sullivan (RCSEd) to Fiona Sinclair (RCSEd) - discussing timeline of Eljamel's involvement - 20/05/2014 to 27/05/2014 |
Section 1 |
| ELJ-00553 - Eljamel Inquiry - Scottish Information Commissioner - "New FOI ruling finds NHS Tayside fell 'significantly short' in its handling of Eljamel request" - 11/08/2026 [Publicly Available] |
Section 1 |
| G0001-00002 - Liz Smith (MSP) - Email chain from [Z0003] to Liz Smith Correspondence and Report - 10/08/2016 - 17/10/2016 |
Section 1 |
| G0001-00024 - Liz Smith (MSP) - CV of Sam Eljamel - May 2009 |
Section 1 |
| G0001-00032 - Liz Smith (MSP) - Witness Statement of Liz Smith, MSP - 10/03/2026 |
Section 1 |
